Saturday, October 13, 2012

Crowdsourced Q&A #1: Brony Study


A tribute to Brony Study by ~KryptidAnimals on deviantART

We blog moderators here at EqM have been chatting about the possibility of organizing Q&As with various constituent groups and individuals in the brony community. But these will be Q&As with a twist. We will be collecting our questions from you, our commenters, right in the comments section!

For our first Q&A, we will be collecting questions for Dr. Redden and Dr. Edwards, the scientists working on the Brony Study research project. These two scientists, with the eager aid of tens of thousands of bronies, have collected an incredible amount of data about the brony community (since very early on in the brony community's existence, when compared to studies of other online communities). This data set has helped them test the veracity of many early-forming stereotypes about the brony community as well as create a typology to help describe and interpret the brony community, and maybe one day it will yield hints about the nature of the earliest phases of community formation on the internet: a notoriously difficult area to study. Dr Redden and Dr Edwards are currently preparing for their "longitudinal study", an experiment where they will collect data over the course of a few years to gain insights into how the brony community changes over time.

So if you have any questions for Dr. Redden and Dr. Edwards, please leave them in the comments below! Also if you don't have IntenseDebate or just don't want to comment here, there is now a thread up on Ponychan for anonymous commenting.

Comments (30)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Go on folks; post away. If there's anything we're not sure we want to give to Redden and Edwards, we blog mods will let you know.
...
lolnope. All the other mods seem to be out enjoying their Saturday! XD
Well at least I'll still provide feedback.
1 reply · active 650 weeks ago
Understandable. According to his Skype it's Swat's birthday today too.
What gave them a reason to start studying us in particular?and what will they do with the data after there studys are complete?
What possesed these two brave souls to want to research the Bronies? Were they given the task or did they just take an interest in the fandom and its origins/mindset/where it's going/etc?

Also, is there anything that they are "looking for" specifically by studying Bronies? Are they only concerned with how the fandom works and develops or is this to help study Internet culture or something else?

Edit: And I forgot one more. Im sure Dr.s Redden and Edwards have been exposed to several parts of the fandom and even the show in their studies. Have their studies on us showed them something about themselves? I'm not asking if they are "changing" into Bronies (that would obviously muck up their research, Bronies researching Bronies and all.) But have they taken more interest in art, music, other things the fandom explores, being a better person, etc?
Are they looking into what the fandom produces or just the people who are in it?
Will they be interviewing top bronys like seth. And the blog6 on how they help fuel the community with the info they gather for the community?
Question for Mike: Did they contact you or something?
1 reply · active 650 weeks ago
I contacted them, and Dr. Redden said they don't mind (within reasonable bounds). I've been keeping in touch since Edwards and I met at the January BroNYCon.
Will they be studying cons or are they just focusing on the internet aspect of the community?
How many stages are they planning for this study? Or is it, perhaps, going to be indefinite, with periodic result reports?
6 replies · active 650 weeks ago
The Longitudinal one?
Yes, and all the brony community studies they're planning on. I remember their report during Bronycon, and, if I'm not mistaken (didn't check to refresh the memory), it was their second one.
All right. That's a good question then.
Hey I have a question: can I be in your video game? :D
The other mods are toying with that idea. If you see them, ask them. I have no idea what the plan is for that.
I think I'll add my own question for them... lol.
"What has your data proven most certainly? What's your lowest alpha value?"
Question to mike.will you guys keep us informed of how the study progresses?
1 reply · active 650 weeks ago
Well if I learn anything while communicating with Redden and Edwards, I'll make sure to ask them if I can put it here on EqM.
Mike, how did your post time travel like that *looks at post time*
4 replies · active 650 weeks ago
The power of friendship!!!!!
YEAH!! FRIENDSHIP!!

Yeah!! Yugioh friendship!!!!
Tia is such a kleptomaniac... Plus, that permanent marker...
chessie2003's avatar

chessie2003 · 650 weeks ago

What do bronies think of "celebrities" within the community (eg John Joseco, Alex S)? Are they resentful of them, do they idolize them? Do they believe they're in it for fame and profit or just for fun? Do bronies wish they were more famous within the community?
1 reply · active 650 weeks ago
Interesting... I don't know if BronyStudy has collected information about this yet, but upon hearing your question, perhaps they will. Anyways, I'm sure they'll know something relevant to this.
I was wondering, the purpose of this study is to try and better define bronies and how they change over time right? So does this study also cover the cause of this phenomenon or its effect on society over time as well?
2 replies · active 650 weeks ago
The longitudinal study, or the whole research project?
Otherwise, good question.
The whole project.
Sorry I didn't specify; I guess that's what happens when I decide to post late at night.

Post a new comment

Comments by